Best Insurance Rates in Newtown Square

Are You Looking For The Best Insurance Rates and Coverage in Newtown Square?

Are you looking to find the best available insurance coverage and price for your home, auto, or business in Newtown Square?

Whether you are looking for Personal Insurance Coverage or Business Insurance Coverage, we can provide the best available options for your needs.

  • Personal Insurance
    • Auto, Home, Renters, Condo, or Motorcycle
  • Business Insurance
    • General Liability, Commercial Auto, Workers Compensation, Professional Liability, Cyber Liability, and more

McCollum Insurance is an Independent Insurance Agency, we work with the best Insurance Companies that serve the Newtown Square area. We have two offices to serve your needs. Feel free to stop in or call, our Manayunk Office or Newtown Square Office.


This is what our clients from Newtown Square say about the service at McCollum Insurance.

I am very happy to insure my car with McCollum Insurance. Kody was exceptional to deal with, she came up with a premium that couldn’t be beaten. I tried several other companies but none of them could come close. Highly recommend McCollum Insurance Agency

Colette R  – Newtown Square

Brian and everyone at McCollum have been amazing to work with! After being with another Erie Agency for the past 10 years, they made the transition seamlessly. They were super efficient, and responsive throughout the whole process. So happy my family & I are in such great hands!
Jillian P – Newtown Square

Customer service is always 100%. Any question gets an immediate response and appropriate guidance if required. have been with this agency for 15-20 years and service has always been top notch. Thanks Brian, and your excellent staff.

Joe S – Newtown Square

Overall service has been excellent. Friendly staff and a pleasure to work with

David H

Outstanding service and very thorough responses to our multiple questions. The prices and coverage can’t be beat!
Jim M – Newtown Square

Researching the many different insurance companies and finding the best fit for us at the best price was fantastic. We are saving over a $1,000 per year on our combined policies with Mccollum Insurance.

Rich C – Newtown Square

Our staff is ready to offer friendly, personalized, and professional advice. We are local, and our staff live and work in your community. We insured many of you neighbors, so give us a call or send us an email to get started with a review of your Insurance.

Request Your Proposal Here

Are you ready to save time, aggravation, and money? The team at McCollum Insurance is here and ready to make the process as painless as possible. We look forward to meeting you!

Call Email Claims Payments